*This article contains spoilers
The long-awaited season two of Nobody Wants This came out on Oct. 23, 2025. Season one, created by Erin Foster, was released on Sept. 26, 2024, and ever since then fans have been eagerly awaiting the second season. To create the compelling narrative, Foster based the show on her relationship with her husband, Simon Tikhman. The show follows the romantic meeting of Noah, a rabbi from an extremely traditional Jewish family, and Joanne, an agnostic podcast host with an obstructed view of love. While they quickly fall for each other, their relationship dynamic becomes complicated due to their different backgrounds; these complications play out in more detail throughout season two.
In season one, romantic sparks immediately start to fly when the two meet at a party. They choose to ignore their feelings for each other since their backgrounds are so different. Eventually, they choose to pursue the relationship. When Joanne shows up at Noah’s temple, his family becomes angered. His mom expresses that she is a threat to his faith and his career as a rabbi. Not only does Noah’s mom hate Joanne, but his sister-in-law, Esther, is not her biggest fan. Esther is best friends with Noah’s ex-fiance, Rebecca, and wants them back together. This dynamic brings complications to their relationship and each of their own lives. Joanne’s life is impacted as she starts to lose her charm on her and her sister’s podcast, as she is now in a relationship. Noah’s life is also impacted when he is told that he has to break up with Joanne in order to be promoted to his dream job as head rabbi. Joanne tries to impress his family to get their mind off the fact that she is not Jewish, but instead, she made an even bigger fool of herself; she brought a charcuterie board with pork (non-kosher) to their house. Although the family hates her, she decides that she will convert for Noah. But, when Rebecca approaches her and apologizes for the lies she told in the past, Joanne realizes how much of a commitment dating Noah really is. She emotionally breaks up with him, because she didn’t want to get in the way of him and his dream job. The season ends with Noah chasing after her, saying that if he has to choose, he will choose her.
With being left on an intense cliff-hanger, viewers were anxiously waiting for the second season. Fans, including myself, found that the narrative in season two was less compelling and more frustrating than the first season. Season two had a lot of potential, as the first season had my eyes glued to the screen, but it didn’t necessarily fulfill the same excitement. It took me a while to finish the second season, because around episode five, it just felt like the show was dragging on. Every episode felt repetitive, and there didn’t seem to be a storyline to each episode. There were a lot of excess storylines that were enjoyable, but took away from the main attraction: Noah and Joanne. For example, in episode five, Joanne goes to a baby naming ceremony that Noah is leading. Although interesting, this episode drifted away from the main plot and focused more on Joanne’s relationship with her middle school ex-best friend and the mother of the baby, Abby. After episode five there was no development as Noah and Joanne continued to have the same problem. Another example is Joanne’s sister, Morgan’s, romantic relationship. This was a funny and intense aspect of the season, but again, fans were expecting a focus on Noah and Joanne’s relationship development, along with Joanne’s conversion. Although season two was good, I think season one set high expectations with the fascinating love story whereas season two they had already fallen in love so there was less development.
In addition to all of these factors, I also felt the last episode, along with the ending, was a letdown. The whole last episode felt so unrealistic, with every couple breaking up. The episode ends with Noah and Joanne back together again, which I was so happy about, but we never find out if she converts for him. Although she expresses her desire to continue Jewish traditions even without Noah, we never find out if she truly converts, which is what the audience was waiting for.
Even though I feel season two does not compare to season one, there are aspects that are outstanding. First of all, I noticed that season two highlighted a lot more Jewish traditions, rules, and beliefs. There are not many shows that include Judaism within, but Nobody Wants This season two accomplished this. This show attracts a variety of audiences, including people who are not Jewish. With this in mind, the show spreads awareness about Jewish rituals, which is vital because there are not many popular shows that include Jewish education. Not only is there Jewish knowledge sprinkled in, but there is a lot of humor in season two. A big source of humor in season two is Morgan. She constantly makes comments that make the audience laugh. Her unexpected, snarky comments are what keep the audience smiling throughout the show. Aside from Morgan’s humor, the show consists of many funny scenes. Humor is not the only thing that keeps the audience smiling. Noah and Joanne’s chemistry resonates with the audience, leaving them with a happy feeling; their relationship is so genuine that the viewer can not help from smiling at the TV. If you are looking for a feel-good, laughable show, Nobody Wants This is the one for you.
Overall, I absolutely love this show, but season one was a much easier watch than season two. I still enjoyed watching the show, but I felt less compelled to continue watching once it started to get repetitive. I, without a doubt, recommend that everyone should watch Nobody Wants This, as it is a light-hearted, fun show to watch.
